| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| The other main lead, a yellow critter who's lazy, cynical, and quite frankly the only normal one | Charlie | 100%
|
| One of the two main leads, a very optimistic and cheerful pink critter | Pim | 99%
|
| One of the employees at Smiling Friends, a red critter who's strangely obsessed with cheese | Alan | 96%
|
| The head of the Smiling Friends company, a big-headed, insane human | Mr. Boss | 93%
|
| The second episode's client, a celebrity who ruined his own career | Mr. Frog | 92%
|
| Another Smiling Friends employee, a small green critter who only speaks in gibberish | Glep | 91%
|
| The third episode's client, a cowardly little guy obsessed with an online game who's girlfriend dumped him | Shrimp | 89%
|
| The first episode's client, a depressed and suicidal individual who later starts his own extermination business | Desmond | 82%
|
| A red restaurant mascot | Ketchup | 80%
|
| A yellow restaurant mascot | Mustard | 80%
|
| An elf of the Enchanted Forest who helps #1 and #2 on their journey, later turns out to be a deranged stalker | Mip | 76%
|
| A restaurant owner who was killed | Simon S. Salty | 72%
|
| Small white and gray restaurant mascots | Salt and Pepper | 70%
|
| The sixth episode's client, a royal individual of the Enchanted Forest who couldn't smile for her portrait because of the above character | The Princess | 70%
|
| Thinks he's a mascot, is actually just a puddle on the floor | Grease | 63%
|
| Evil versions of #1 and #2 | Grim and Gnarly | 62%
|
| An evil individual who #2 tries to help smile after he dies | Satan | 55%
|
| A blue critter who came onto the show via a text vote, is later shown to be dead | Smormu | 52%
|
| A demonic creature who is accused of doing blackface, is later torn apart | Forest Demon | 49%
|
| A woman in the third episode who was thought to be #8's girlfriend who dumped him, but is actually just a regular individual who's previous boyfriend died in a motorcycle accident. She does end up with #8 at the end, however | Jennifer | 49%
|
| A three-dimensional character who often cries and likes balloons | 3D Squelton | 44%
|
| Two crazy restaurant mascots | The Fun Twins | 30%
|
| A man who lives in the walls of Smiling Friends | Wall Guy | 23%
|
| A bulky restaurant mascot who has a drug problem, causing him to defecate in his costume | Crazy Cup | 16%
|