| Hint | Extra Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dean: I was a demon. | Paper Moon | Oh, you were a demon? Oh, I didn't realize that. | 95%
|
| Dean: Planes crash! | Everybody Loves A Clown | And apparently, clowns kill! | 89%
|
| Becky: I just want someone who loves me for me! Is that too much to ask? | Season 7, Time For A Wedding! | If you want somebody to love you for you, maybe don't drug them. | 89%
|
| Dean: Hey there, Sam. What's happening? | Changing Channels | Oh, nothing. Um. Just the end of the world. | 84%
|
| Cliff: I... I got rights. You can't – | Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie | I'm the federal government, pal. I can do whatever I want. | 79%
|
| Jess: And where's your costume? | Pilot | You know how I feel about Halloween. | 79%
|
| Rowena: From the neck down, is he smooth like a Ken doll? | Regarding Dean | I don't know, and I'm not checking either. | 74%
|
| Molly: Hunting for what? Dean: Ghosts. | Roadkill | D... d... don't... Sugarcoat it for her. | 68%
|
| Dean: Maybe? Maybe!! What if you were wrong? | Route 666 | Huh. Honestly, that thought hadn't occurred to me. | 68%
|
| Misha: Ooh, "priority."what's in it? | The French Mistake | I bought part of a dead person. | 63%
|
| Lucifer: Whatever happened to the Sam Winchester who was bold, decisive, and ready to sacrifice for the greater good? | The Devil In The Details | Right here. | 63%
|
| Dean: I can't believe you called Rowena. | Regarding Dean | I can't believe you rode Larry. | 58%
|
| Jake: Salt is a weapon? | All Hell Breaks Loose Part 1 | It's a brave new world. | 58%
|
| Dean: Wow. Your nerdiness knows no bounds. | Baby | You're welcome. | 58%
|
| Dean: Exactly. We get off-book. We never make it to the end. It's opposite day. It says that we, uh, we get into a fight. So, no fighting. No research for you... | The Monster At The End Of This Book | No bacon cheeseburger for you. | 53%
|
| Dean: Sam Winchester, having trust issues with a demon. Well, better late than never. | Abandon All Hope | Thank you again for your continued support. | 53%
|
| Clif: We're not doing anything illegal, are we? | The French Mistake | Would it make you feel better if we said no? | 53%
|
| Osiris: That's for me to decide. Now go away. | Defending Your Life | But he – he has the right to an attorney. Doesn't he? | 47%
|
| Hallucifer: Hmm. Latin – not suspicious at all. | Repo Man | I've never seen this spell before. | 47%
|
| Wayne: Angels. Please. I’m talking about real magic, sonny. From my side of the fence. Got a way of getting in back doors. | Clap Your Hands If You Believe | So you’re my blue fairy? You can make me a real boy again? | 47%
|
| Timmy: Hey. That's mine. | Out With The Old | Kid, this would be a really good time for a lesson in gratitude. Lucky for you, I'm too tired. | 42%
|
| Ruby: Mmm. These are amazing. It's like deep-fried crack. Try some. | The Kids Are Alright | That knife you had. You can kill demons with that thing? | 42%
|
| Jonny: What? | Mannequin 3: The Reckoning | You know what? You're lucky you are the most suspicious interview of all time. I figured something like this would happen. | 42%
|
| Dean: I'm gonna throw up. | Fan Fiction | I mean, I gotta say, it's kind of charming. The production value, and the... No ? No, no. I'm gonna check for EMF. You look for... cursed objects. | 37%
|
| Charlie: Thanks for saving the world and stuff. Sorry you have zero luck with the ladies. | Pac-Man Fever | Wha-? We need to find every single copy of those books and burn them. | 32%
|