| Character | Description | Actor | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Frank T.J. Mackey | Seduce and Destroy | Tom Cruise | 99%
|
| Linda Partridge | Trophy wife pill popper | Julianne Moore | 85%
|
| Phil Parma | Caring nurse | Philip Seymour Hoffman | 75%
|
| Jim Kurring | Police officer | John C. Reilly | 48%
|
| Donnie Smith | Washed-up "Quiz Kid" | William H. Macy | 46%
|
| Jimmy Gator | Host of What Do Kids Know? | Philip Baker Hall | 31%
|
| Luis | Adult contestant | Luis Guzman | 30%
|
| Earl Partridge | Ailing man | Jason Robards | 29%
|
| Cynthia | Works for What Do Kids Know? | Felicity Huffman | 17%
|
| Delmer Darion | The scuba diver | Patton Oswalt | 12%
|
| Worm | A wanted man | Orlando Jones | 9%
|