| Hint | Captain | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| The First Avenger | Captain America | 95%
|
| Pirate captain whose hand was eaten by a croc | Captain Hook | 87%
|
| Seeks revenge on a white whale | Captain Ahab | 85%
|
| Captain of the Nautilus | Captain Nemo | 77%
|
| His ship was hijacked by Somali pirates. | Captain Phillips | 77%
|
| Spiced rum mascot, or 17th-century Welsh privateer | Captain Morgan | 62%
|
| Superhero Carol Danvers (Not DC) | Captain Marvel | 56%
|
| Duo of 1973's "Love Will Keep Us Together" | Captain & Tennille | 44%
|
| Bob Keshan title character of kids' series ('55–'84) | Captain Kangaroo | 36%
|
| Eco-hero with five powers combined | Captain Planet | 36%
|
| Superhero who is a hypnotized principal | Captain Underpants | 28%
|
| Magic Band leader of Trout Mask Replica | Captain Beefheart | 18%
|
| The world's first superhero...with Teen Angels | Captain Caveman | 15%
|
| Superflu outbreak in Stephen King's The Stand | Captain Trips | 10%
|
| Manga series focusing on soccer | Captain Tsubasa | 8%
|
| Ouija spirit that Regan talks with in The Exorcist | Captain Howdy | 5%
|