| Year | Actor | Hint | Movie | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2004 | Tom Hanks | On Christmas Eve, a young boy is invited aboard a train to the North Pole. | The Polar Express | 97%
|
| 1994 | Tim Allen | Scott Calvin must replace Santa after accidentally causing him to fall from his roof. | The Santa Clause | 94%
|
| 2004 | Ed Asner | A human raised by Santa's elves goes to New York to meet his father. | Elf | 90%
|
| 2003 | Billy Bob Thornton | A sex-addicted cursing alcoholic thief gets a job as a mall Santa. | Bad Santa | 87%
|
| 1947 | Edmund Gwenn | A department store Santa Claus claims to be the real Santa. | Miracle on 34th Street | 71%
|
| 1983 | Jeff Gillen | The Santa at Higbee's tells Ralphie he'll shoot his eye out. | A Christmas Story | 68%
|
| 1966 | Stan Francis | Stop-motion TV special based on the song: Santa needs help in the snowstorm. | Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer | 65%
|
| 1993 | Ed Ivory | Santa is imprisoned by Oogie Boogie, a bogeyman with a passion for gambling. | The Nightmare Before Christmas | 48%
|
| 2018 | Kurt Russell | After two children cause Santa's sleigh to crash, they must help him deliver presents. | The Christmas Chronicles | 32%
|
| 1970 | Mickey Rooney | Stop-motion TV special based on the song: Santa's origin story | Santa Claus is Comin' to Town | 29%
|
| 1985 | David Huddleston | Santa tries to save an elf who's been manipulated by a toy company executive. | Santa Claus: {The} {Movie} | 29%
|
| 1964 | John Call | Sci-fi comedy regularly listed among the worst movies of all time | Santa Claus {Conquers} {the} {Martians} | 26%
|
| 2022 | David Harbour | Santa fights mercenaries who have taken a wealthy family hostage. | Violent Night | 26%
|
| Robert Brian Wilson | Christmas slasher film in which a spree killer dons a Santa costume | Silent Night, Deadly Night | 23%
| |
| 1988 | Al "Red Dog" Weber | In film-within-the-film The Night the Reindeer Died, Santa defends the North Pole with machine guns. | Scrooged | 19%
|
| 1988 | Douglas Seale | An aging Santa attempts to get TV host Joe Caruthers to replace him. KnowhutImean? | Ernest Saves Christmas | 16%
|