| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| How many times is Marshall allowed to slap Barney? | 5 | 97%
|
| What tattoo does Ted have to get tattoo removal surgery for? | A butterfly | 94%
|
| By the end of season 4 Barney celebrates a milestone, how many women has he slept with? | 200 | 91%
|
| What is Robins stage name as a Canadian pop singer? | Robin Sparkles | 91%
|
| What fruit does Ted mysteriously wake up to after a drunken night out? | Pineapple | 90%
|
| What profession is Lily's doppelganger? | A Stripper | 84%
|
| What instrument does Ted steal for Robin? | a blue french horn | 83%
|
| What is the year Ted is narrating the story from? | 2030 | 82%
|
| When Ted and Barney take over Maclaren's bar what do they call it? | Puzzles | 82%
|
| Where in New York does the show take place? | Manhattan | 81%
|
| What life-size action figure does Barney have in his apartment? | A Stormtrooper | 79%
|
| What is the name of the building GNB tear down? | The Arcadian | 79%
|
| Which company did Ted, Marshall and Barney all work for at one point? | Goliath National Bank | 78%
|
| Who does Ted wait for every halloween? | The slutty pumpkin | 78%
|
| What is the name of the mother of Teds children? | Tracy | 77%
|
| What’s the name of the gang’s most familiar bartender? | Carl | 75%
|
| How often does the “naked man maneuver” work? | 2 out of 3 | 74%
|
| What was “eating a sandwich” actually a euphemism for? | smoking weed | 74%
|
| What is Barney’s most hated nickname? | Swarley | 74%
|
| What did Barney have to wear for a year after losing a bet? | A ducky tie | 71%
|
| Who does Barney believe is his father? | Bob Barker | 71%
|
| What profession is Barneys doppleganger? | Doctor | 71%
|
| What is the name of Barney’s brother? | James | 70%
|
| How long was Ted with Stella before proposing? | 3 months | 62%
|
| What profession is Ted’s doppelganger? | A Mexican wrestler | 60%
|
| What is the name of Barneys favourite strip club that Quinn works at? | the lusty leopard | 58%
|
| What phrase does Robin constantly say that Teds students make into a game? | But umm | 53%
|
| What is the name of the board game Marshall creates? | Marshgammon | 49%
|
| Where did Barney first meet Ted and thus became friends with the group? | a urinal | 48%
|
| What law school did Marshall attend at the start of the series? | Columbia | 44%
|
| What college did Ted, Marshall and Lily all go to? | Wesleyan University | 38%
|
| Ted and Barney harmonize with their future selves on a cover of which song? | The Longest time | 27%
|
| What did Barney want to be when he was young? | Magician | 19%
|
| How many cups of mayonnaise does Marshalls mum put in salad? | 16 cups | 16%
|