| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Hammerin' Hank | Hank Aaron | 95%
|
| Shoeless Joe | Joe Jackson | 92%
|
| Mr. October | Reggie Jackson | 89%
|
| Stan the Man | Stan Musial | 86%
|
| The Big Hurt | Frank Thomas | 84%
|
| The Ryan Express | Nolan Ryan | 84%
|
| The Sultan of Swat | Babe Ruth | 81%
|
| The Big Unit | Randy Johnson | 81%
|
| Iron Horse | Lou Gehrig | 68%
|
| The Wizard of Oz | Ozzie Smith | 68%
|
| Charlie Hustle | Pete Rose | 68%
|
| Donnie Baseball | Don Mattingly | 59%
|
| The Splendid Splinter | Ted Williams | 41%
|
| Oil Can Boyd | Dennis Boyd | 35%
|
| Nails | Len Dykstra | 5%
|