| Losing Team | Winning Team | Score | Season | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kansas City Chiefs | Los Angeles Rams | 54-51 | 2018 | 94%
|
| Baltimore Colts | Los Angeles Rams | 70-27 | 1950 | 94%
|
| Miami Dolphins | New York Jets | 51-45 (OT) | 1986 | 94%
|
| Arizona Cardinals | New York Jets | 56-35 | 2008 | 94%
|
| Tampa Bay Buccaneers | New York Jets | 62-38 | 1985 | 94%
|
| New York Giants | Washington Redskins | 72-41 | 1966 | 94%
|
| Cleveland Browns | Cincinnati Bengals | 58-48 | 2004 | 88%
|
| Dallas Cowboys | Denver Broncos | 51-48 | 2013 | 88%
|
| Denver Broncos | Miami Dolphins | 70-20 | 2023 | 88%
|
| Atlanta Falcons | Pittsburgh Steelers | 57-33 | 1966 | 88%
|
| Cincinnati Bengals | Cleveland Browns | 51-45 | 2007 | 85%
|
| Pittsburgh Steelers | Los Angeles Chargers | 54-44 | 1985 | 85%
|
| Houston Oilers | Oakland Raiders | 52-49 | 1963 | 85%
|
| Cincinnati Bengals | San Diego Chargers | 49-41 | 2006 | 85%
|
| New York Giants | New Orleans Saints | 52-49 | 2016 | 82%
|
| St. Louis Cardinals | New Orleans Saints | 51-42 | 1969 | 82%
|
| Detroit Lions | New Orleans Saints | 52-38 | 2017 | 82%
|
| Kansas City Chiefs | Seattle Seahawks | 51-48 (OT) | 1983 | 82%
|
| Detroit Lions | Seattle Seahawks | 48-45 | 2022 | 82%
|
| New York Giants | Chicago Cardinals | 63-35 | 1948 | 79%
|
| Washington Redskins | Green Bay Packers | 48-47 | 1983 | 76%
|
| Los Angeles Chargers | New York Titans | 50-43 | 1960 | 73%
|
| Denver Broncos | New York Titans | 46-45 | 1962 | 73%
|
| New Orleans Saints | San Francisco 49ers | 48-46 | 2019 | 73%
|
| Los Angeles Rams | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | 55-40 | 2019 | 73%
|