| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Kraken | Ed Teach/ Blackbeard | 99%
|
| Lighthouse | Stede Bonnet | 88%
|
| Dagger | Jim | 87%
|
| Black | Black Pete | 83%
|
| Pinkie-Toe | Izzy Hands | 81%
|
| 40 Orange Cake | Roach | 74%
|
| Bojack Horseman | Calico Jack | 51%
|
| So-So | Lucious | 24%
|