| Rank | Caps | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 19* | 62* | Ragnar Sigurðsson | 76%
|
| 19 | 62 | Helgi Sigurðsson | 72%
|
| 15 | 65 | Indriði Sigurðsson | 72%
|
| 7 | 73 | Arnór Guðjohnsen | 55%
|
| 3* | 88* | Eiður Guðjohnsen | 55%
|
| 15* | 65* | Aron Gunnarsson | 28%
|
| 5 | 74 | Brynjar Björn Gunnarsson | 28%
|
| 1 | 104 | Rúnar Kristinsson | 21%
|
| 18* | 63* | Birkir Már Sævarsson | 17%
|
| 4 | 80 | Guðni Bergsson | 17%
|
| 5 | 74 | Birkir Kristinsson | 10%
|
| 12 | 69 | Sævar Jónsson | 10%
|
| 15 | 65 | Sigurður Jónsson | 10%
|
| 9 | 71 | Arnar Grétarsson | 3%
|
| 9 | 71 | Árni Gautur Arason | 3%
|
| 11 | 70 | Atli Eðvaldsson | 3%
|
| 2 | 89 | Hermann Hreiðarsson | 3%
|
| 14 | 66 | Eyjólfur Sverrisson | 0%
|
| 13 | 67 | Marteinn Geirsson | 0%
|
| 8 | 72 | Ólafur Þórðarson | 0%
|