| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Had a book about birds in his prison cell | Dahmer | 90%
|
| Fed the guy above peanuts to make him stop playing the trumpet during TV time | Kemper | 18%
|
| Killed women for their shoes/feet | Brudos | 10%
|
| Killed to prevent earthquakes | Mullin | 5%
|
| Had a blender filled with blood | Chase | 3%
|
| Collected teeth from the victims | Junni | 3%
|
| Collected teeth from the victims | Junni | 3%
|
| Publicly sang about frying a baby, Killing its father and raping its mother | Ng | 3%
|
| Had a small penis | DeAngelo | 2%
|
| Made shoes for hamsters, had a hole with feces and semen | Kallinger | 2%
|
| Reported his crimes to the police via a phone with a whiny voice | Stephani | 2%
|
| Had a dream in 1986 in which his dad told him to drink the saliva of 70 young women to become a mystic healer | Suradji | 2%
|
| Played dungeons and dragons with teens in a sewage | Butts | 1%
|
| Had a "dead body on board" sign on his car | Gaskins | 1%
|
| Invited labourers to his home and killed them if they didn't behave as he expected | Jha | 1%
|
| Defecated in a victim's bathtub | Kaczynski | 1%
|
| Wanted to kill inmates with bees | Roubal | 1%
|