| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| That starts with the word "Saint" | St. Kitts and Nevis | St. Lucia | St. Vincent and the Grenadines | 98%
|
| With a population of African descent above 90% | Haiti | St. Kitts and Nevis | Jamaica | Bahamas | 85%
|
| That starts with a vowel | Antigua and Barbuda | El Salvador | 82%
|
| With a JetPunk abbreviation | United States | Dominican Republic | 75%
|
| With a population below 110k | St. Kitts and Nevis | Dominica | Antigua and Barbuda | 69%
|
| With a gross national income per capita below $4,500 | Haiti | Nicaragua | Honduras | El Salvador | Belize | Guatemala | 63%
|
| Without English or Spanish as an official language | Haiti | 57%
|
| That is entirely south of Aruba | Costa Rica | Panama | Trinidad and Tobago | 45%
|
| That could be considered transcontinental | Panama | Trinidad and Tobago | 36%
|
| That has mainland within 16 miles of an external territory of another country | Canada | Dominica | 34%
|
| That has a flag without white | Bahamas | Grenada | Jamaica | 25%
|
| With three of the same vowel and no other vowels | Bahamas | Canada | Panama | 23%
|
| With an average elevation below 1,000 ft (304.8 m) | Belize | Nicaragua | Trinidad and Tobago | 18%
|
| Whose capital city starts with "Saint" | Antigua and Barbuda | Grenada | 16%
|
| With a water area percentage above 10% | Bahamas | 11%
|