| 18 | Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 12 | daughter of the mayor (as of season 3) | Kelly | 93%
|
| 2 | 1's younger sister | Rose | 88%
|
| 1 | 1800s boy and former villain | Charles | 86%
|
| 7 | owner of two cafes & former villain | Ida | 86%
|
| 14 | implied future actress | Darbie | 84%
|
| 8 | piano teacher | Gina | 84%
|
| 13 | protector with 12 & 14 | Hannah | 84%
|
| 9 | was disguised as Jill | Caroline | 81%
|
| 10 | protector along with 9 | RJ | 70%
|
| 11 | is owner & chef at Saphrön, | Noelle | 63%
|
| 6 | O.C and 12's grandma | Rebecca | 54%
|
| 15 | daughter of a past protector | Zoe | 49%
|
| 16 | step-brother of 15 | Leo | 37%
|
| 3 | Went forward in time to marry Erin | Ian | 26%
|
| 17 | downstairs neighbor of 13 &16 | Ishita | 14%
|
| 5 | was protector with 4 & 3 | Clint | 7%
|
| 4 | was protector with 3 & 5 | Folsom | 7%
|