| Rank | Crew Member | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Captain | Harold Lee Rosbach | 100%
|
| Bosun (Ep 1-16) & First Officer (Ep 16) | Eddie Lucas | 67%
|
| Chef | Rachel Hargrove | 60%
|
| Chief Stew | Francesca Rubi | 53%
|
| Deckhand (Ep 1-7) | Shane Coppersmith | 47%
|
| Stewardess (Ep 1-3), Second Stew (Ep 3-8), Third Stew (Ep 9-15) | Elizabeth Frankini | 40%
|
| Deckhand | James Hough | 40%
|
| Third Stew (Ep 3-16) | Ashling Lorger | 33%
|
| Stewardess (Ep 1-3), Deckhand (Ep 3-13), Lead Deckhand (Ep 13-16) | Isabelle Wouters | 33%
|
| Deckhand (Ep 1) | Avery Russell | 27%
|
| Deckhand (Ep 8-16) | Robert Phillips | 27%
|