| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Charismatic criminal | Boyd Crowder | 100%
|
| Stenson wearing US Marshal | Raylan Givens | 92%
|
| Chief Deputy | Art Mullen | 75%
|
| Love interest to both of the above | Ava Crowder | 75%
|
| Father, veteran & criminal | Arlo Givens | 67%
|
| Level-headed US Masrhal | Rachel Brooks | 67%
|
| Former sniper, US Marshal | Tim Gutterson | 67%
|
| Ex-wife of #1 | Winona Hawkins | 67%
|
| Dimwitted criminal | Dewey Crowe | 58%
|
| AUSA | David Vasquez | 42%
|
| Criminal boss, homemade apple pie | Mags Bennett | 42%
|
| Boss of Detroit Crime Family | Theo Tonin | 42%
|
| Criminal investor, butcher | Ellstin Limehouse | 33%
|
| Mafia middle-man | Wynn Duffy | 33%
|
| Paraplegic brother, criminal | Dickie Bennett | 25%
|
| Widow, secret mastermind | Katherine Hale | 17%
|
| Teenaged orphan, dealer & grower | Loretta McCready | 17%
|
| The Carpetbagger | Robert Quarles | 17%
|
| Colorado criminal & businessman | Avery Markham | 8%
|
| Constable of Harlan county | Bob Sweeney | 0%
|
| Greek hitman | Ethan Picker | 0%
|
| Underboss, attempted a coup | Nick Augustine | 0%
|