| Answer | Placement | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Blue Puzzle Piece | 24th | 100%
|
| Nacho | 14th | 100%
|
| Overgrown Fence | 18th | 100%
|
| Poorly Drawn Circle | 20th | 100%
|
| Ruby | 25th | 100%
|
| Ball | 17th | 75%
|
| Bar of Corn | 19th | 75%
|
| Fishbone | 21th | 75%
|
| GameKing | 22th | 75%
|
| Gum Gum Fruit | 12th | 75%
|
| Dirt Block | 16th | 50%
|
| Hot Pepper | 23th | 50%
|
| Stumpy | ??th (rejoined) | 50%
|
| Traffic Cone | 15th | 50%
|
| Woomster | 13th | 25%
|