| Clue | Form | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Creature | Pennywise | 74%
|
| Creature | Mummy | 48%
|
| Creature | Werewolf | 48%
|
| Sick Person | Leper | 44%
|
| Person | Georgie Denbrough | 34%
|
| True Form | Deadlights | 28%
|
| Person | Alvin Marsh | 26%
|
| Creature | Giant Bird | 18%
|
| Creature | Giant Spider | 18%
|
| Creature | Dracula | 16%
|
| Creature | Creature from the Black Lagoon | 15%
|
| Person/Creature | Mrs Kersh/Witch | 15%
|
| Person | Belch Huggins | 11%
|
| Person | Patrick Hockstetter | 11%
|
| Person | Head of Stan Uris | 10%
|
| Person | Victor Criss | 10%
|
| Body Part | Crawling Eye | 8%
|
| Person | Dorsey Corcoran | 8%
|
| Person | Betty Ripsom | 7%
|
| Animal | Doberman Pinscher | 7%
|
| Creature | Frankenstein's Monster | 7%
|
| Creature | Paul Bunyan Statue | 7%
|
| Creature | Ghost Moon | 5%
|
| Person | Greta Bowie | 5%
|
| Person | Tony Tracker | 5%
|
| Creature | Winged Leeches | 5%
|
| Creaure/Human | Decomposing Children's Corpses | 3%
|
| Creature | Jaws Shark | 3%
|
| Person | Jimmy Donlin's Mother | 3%
|
| Creature | Piranhas | 3%
|