| Seasons | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| 7-8 (Pearl Islands-All Stars) | Rupert Boneham | 100%
|
| 19-20 (Samoa-Heroes vs. Villains) | Russell Hantz | 100%
|
| 15-16 (China-Micronesia) | Amanda Kimmel | 96%
|
| 15-16 (China-Micronesia) | James Clement | 96%
|
| 10-11 (Palau-Guatemala) | Stephenie LaGrossa | 96%
|
| 49-50 (Survivor 49-Survivor 50: In the Hands of the Fans) | Rizo Velovic | 91%
|
| 33-34 (Millennials vs. Gen X-Game Changers) | Zeke Smith | 91%
|
| 44-45 (Survivor 44-Survivor 45) | Bruce Perreault | 87%
|
| 25-26 (Philippines-Caramoan) | Malcolm Freberg | 87%
|
| 49-50 (Survivor 49-Survivor 50: In the Hands of the Fans) | Savannah Louie | 87%
|
| 10-11 (Palau-Guatemala) | Bobby Jon Drinkard | 83%
|
| 30-31 (Worlds Apart-Cambodia) | Shirin Oskooi | 83%
|
| 30-31 (Worlds Apart-Cambodia) | Joe Anglim | 78%
|
| 33-34 (Millennials vs. Gen X-Game Changers) | Michaela Bradshaw | 74%
|