| Original Album/Year of Release | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Piano Man, 1973 | Piano Man | 97%
|
| An Innocent Man, 1983 | Uptown Girl | 78%
|
| Piano Man, 1973 | Captain Jack | 75%
|
| The Storm Front, 1989 | We Didn't Start the Fire | 75%
|
| River of Dreams, 1993 | The River of Dreams | 73%
|
| The Stranger, 1977 | Only the Good Die Young | 70%
|
| Turnstiles, 1976 | New York State of Mind | 69%
|
| An Innocent Man, 1983 | An Innocent Man | 64%
|
| The Stranger, 1977 | Movin' Out (Anthony's Song) | 64%
|
| The Stranger, 1977 | Scenes from an Italian Restaurant | 64%
|
| Glass Houses, 1980 | You May Be Right | 64%
|
| The Stranger, 1977 | Just the Way You Are | 63%
|
| 52nd Street, 1978 | My Life | 63%
|
| Streetlife Serenede, 1974 | The Entertainer | 59%
|
| The Nylon Curtain, 1982 | Allentown | 58%
|
| 52nd Street, 1978 | Big Shot | 56%
|
| The Nylon Curtain, 1982 | Goodnight Saigon | 55%
|
| Glass Houses, 1980 | It's Still Rock and Roll to Me | 55%
|
| The Nylon Curtain, 1982 | Pressure | 52%
|
| The Stranger, 1977 | She's Always a Woman | 52%
|
| An Innocent Man, 1983 | The Longest Time | 52%
|
| The Bridge, 1986 | A Matter of Trust | 50%
|
| Glass Houses, 1980 | Don't Ask Me Why | 50%
|
| Turnstiles, 1976 | Say Goodbye to Hollywood | 50%
|
| 52nd Street, 1978 | Honesty | 48%
|
| Turnstiles, 1976 | Miami 2017 (Seen the Lights Go Out on Broadway) | 48%
|
| An Innocent Man, 1983 | Tell Her About It | 48%
|
| The Storm Front, 1989 | The Downeaster Alexa | 48%
|
| The Storm Front, 1989 | I Go to Extremes | 42%
|
| The Bridge, 1986 | Baby Grand (Duet with Ray Charles) | 41%
|
| River of Dreams, 1993 | Lullabye (Goodnight, My Angel) | 39%
|
| The Storm Front, 1989 | And So It Goes | 38%
|
| Turnstiles, 1976 | Prelude/Angry Young Man | 38%
|
| River of Dreams, 1993 | All About Soul (Remix) | 31%
|
| Songs in the Attic, 1981 | She's Got a Way (Live) | 31%
|
| Glass Houses, 1980 | All for Leyna | 30%
|
| The Bridge, 1986 | This Is the Time | 30%
|
| An Innocent Man, 1983 | Leave a Tender Moment Alone | 28%
|
| The Storm Front, 1989 | Leningrad | 28%
|
| Piano Man, 1973 | You're My Home | 25%
|
| Piano Man, 1973 | Worse Comes to Worst | 13%
|
| Fantasies and Delusions, 2001 | Invention in C minor | 5%
|
| Fantasies and Delusions, 2001 | Waltz no. 1 (Nunley's Carousel) | 2%
|