| Position | Spieler | Fußballverein | % Korrekt |
|---|---|---|---|
| MF | Fritz Walter | 1.FC Kaiserslautern | 98%
|
| ST | Ottmar Walter | 1.FC Kaiserslautern | 98%
|
| ST | Helmut Rahn | Rot-Weiss Essen | 96%
|
| TW | Toni Turek | Fortuna Düsseldorf | 91%
|
| TR | Sepp Herberger | - | 79%
|
| ST | Max Morlock | 1.FC Nürnberg | 77%
|
| ST | Hans Schäfer | 1.FC Köln | 65%
|
| MF | Horst Eckel | 1.FC Kaiserslautern | 65%
|
| MF | Charly Mai | Greuther Fürth | 61%
|
| AW | Werner Liebrich | 1.FC Kaiserslautern | 58%
|
| AW | Werner Kohlmeyer | 1.FC Kaiserslautern | 56%
|
| AW | Jupp Posipal | Hamburger SV | 49%
|
| TW | Heinz Kwiatkowski | Borussia Dortmund | 35%
|
| ST | Berni Klodt | FC Schalke 04 | 33%
|
| AW | Hans Bauer | Bayern München | 30%
|
| Co-TR | Albert Sing | BSC Young Boys Bern | 28%
|
| ST | Alfred Pfaff | Eintracht Frankfurt | 28%
|
| AW | Herbert Erhardt | Greuther Fürth | 28%
|
| MF | Paul Mebus | 1.FC Köln | 28%
|
| ST | Richard Herrmann | FSV Frankfurt | 28%
|
| TW | Heinz Kubsch | FK Pirmasens | 26%
|
| AW | Fritz Laband | Hamburger SV | 25%
|
| MF | Karl-Heinz Metzner | Hessen Kassel | 25%
|
| MF | Ulrich Biesinger | FC Augsburg | 25%
|