| Date | Opponents | H / A | Competition | Result | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12–09–2025 | Sheffield United | H | Championship | W 5–0 | Jaden Philogene | 92%
|
| 17–05–2000 | Bolton Wanderers | H | First Division play-offs | W 5–3 (a.e.t.) | Jim Magilton | 91%
|
| 02–04–2001 | Southampton | A | Premier League | W 3–0 | Marcus Stewart | 90%
|
| 15–04–2023 | Charlton Athletic | H | League One | W 6–0 | Conor Chaplin | 81%
|
| 16–03–2004 | Walsall | A | First Division | W 3–1 | Darren Bent | 80%
|
| 07–11–2015 | Rotherham United | A | Championship | W 5–2 | Daryl Murphy | 67%
|
| 29–08–2002 | Avenir Beggen | H | UEFA Cup | W 8–1 | Pablo Couñago | 64%
|
| 20–03–2004 | Watford | H | First Division | W 4–1 | Dean Bowditch | 62%
|
| 15–02–2011 | Doncaster Rovers | A | Championship | W 6–0 | Connor Wickham | 58%
|
| 06–08–2016 | Barnsley | H | Championship | W 4–2 | Grant Ward | 58%
|
| 29–10–2006 | Luton Town | H | Championship | W 5–0 | Alan Lee | 52%
|
| 28–09–2021 | Doncaster Rovers | H | League One | W 6–0 | Lee Evans | 52%
|
| 10–11–2007 | Bristol City | H | Championship | W 6–0 | Jon Walters | 37%
|