| Hint | Explanation | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Eberechi Eze | Crystal Palace 1–0 Manchester City | 2025 | 90%
|
| Michael Owen | Liverpool 2–1 Arsenal | 2001 | 76%
|
| Roger Osborne | Ipswich Town 1–0 Arsenal | 1978 | 71%
|
| Youri Tielemans | Leicester City 1–0 Chelsea | 2021 | 69%
|
| Ricky Villa | Tottenham Hotspur 3–2 Manchester City (replay) | 1981 | 64%
|
| Lawrie Sanchez | Wimbledon 1–0 Liverpool | 1988 | 64%
|
| Alan Sunderland | Arsenal 3–2 Manchester United | 1979 | 59%
|
| Trevor Brooking | West Ham United 1–0 Arsenal | 1980 | 57%
|
| Norman Whiteside | Manchester United 1–0 Everton (a.e.t.) | 1985 | 56%
|
| Paul Rideout | Everton 1–0 Manchester United | 1995 | 54%
|
| Jesse Lingard | Manchester United 2–1 Crystal Palace (a.e.t.) | 2016 | 54%
|
| Nwankwo Kanu | Portsmouth 1–0 Cardiff City | 2008 | 52%
|
| Ian St John | Liverpool 2–1 Leeds United (a.e.t.) | 1965 | 49%
|
| Ian Porterfield | Sunderland 1–0 Leeds United | 1973 | 49%
|
| Ben Watson | Wigan Athletic 1–0 Manchester City | 2013 | 49%
|
| Charlie George | Arsenal 2–1 Liverpool (a.e.t.) | 1971 | 45%
|
| Ted Drake | Arsenal 1–0 Sheffield United | 1936 | 39%
|
| Morton Betts | Wanderers 1–0 Royal Engineers | 1872 | 32%
|
| Billy Meredith | Manchester City 1–0 Bolton Wanderers | 1904 | 32%
|
| Bill Perry | Blackpool 4–3 Bolton Wanderers | 1953 | 25%
|