| Plot | Movie | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Insane asylum patient breaks out and goes on a killing spree in October | Halloween | 87%
|
| A group of people travel to Sweden for the midsummer and are made sacrifices to purge the village of evil | Midsommar | 68%
|
| Researchers in Antarctica must kill off all the creatures hidden among them | The Thing | 64%
|
| A group of friends go on a vacation in the woods and are attacked by various types of creatures | Cabin in the Woods | 52%
|
| A group of people are trapped in an elevator and must figure out which one of them is the devil | Devil (2010) | 52%
|
| In 1977, a late night show goes wrong and unleashes evil in the studio | Late Night with the Devil | 41%
|
| Cosmic entity causes insanity to those who look at it | Bird Box | 31%
|
| Workers of a company are trapped in their building and forced to kill each other | The Belko Experiment | 29%
|
| A man carries on the legacy of a notorious killer who carved out the hearts of his victims and placed them in candy boxes | My Bloody Valentine | 24%
|
| A demon torments a child in his own house, removing all the windows and doors | Skinamarink | 21%
|
| Lovecraftian horrors emerge from a military portal and wreak havoc | The Mist | 16%
|
| Alien on the run befriends two kids and kills a bunch of people and aliens | Psycho Goreman | 5%
|