| Date | Victory | Battle | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| July 1–3, 1863 | Union | Battle of Gettysburg | 95%
|
| July 21, 1861 | Confederate | First Battle of Bull Run | 80%
|
| August 28–30, 1862 | Confederate | Second Battle of Bull Run | 80%
|
| April 25 – May 1, 1862 | Union | Capture of New Orleans | 78%
|
| September 17, 1862 | Union | Battle of Antietam | 77%
|
| May 18 – July 4, 1863 | Union | Siege of Vicksburg | 77%
|
| July 22, 1864 | Union | Battle of Atlanta | 76%
|
| April 12–13, 1861 | Confederate | Battle of Fort Sumter | 76%
|
| December 15–16, 1864 | Union | Battle of Nashville | 61%
|
| August 2–23, 1864 | Union | Battle of Mobile Bay | 60%
|
| April 6–7, 1862 | Union | Battle of Shiloh | 58%
|
| June 6, 1862 | Union | Battle of Memphis | 55%
|
| June 15–18, 1864 | Confederate | Second Battle of Petersburg | 45%
|
| December 13, 1862 | Confederate | Battle of Fredericksburg | 44%
|
| May 5–7, 1864 | Inconclusive | Battle of the Wilderness | 39%
|
| April 30 – May 6, 1863 | Confederate | Battle of Chancellorsville | 38%
|
| September 19–20, 1863 | Confederate | Battle of Chickamauga | 37%
|
| May 31 – June 12, 1864 | Confederate | Battle of Cold Harbor | 31%
|
| September 12–15, 1862 | Confederate | Battle of Harpers Ferry | 31%
|
| December 31, 1862 – January 2, 1863 | Union | Battle of Stones River | 25%
|
| August 10, 1861 | Confederate | Battle of Wilson's Creek | 17%
|
| July 30, 1864 | Confederate | Battle of the Crater | 16%
|
| October 19, 1864 | Union | Battle of Cedar Creek | 7%
|
| July 11, 1861 | Union | Battle of Rich Mountain | 5%
|
| April 9, 1865 | Union | Battle of Appomattox Court House | 2%
|