| Population | Island | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| 11.3 m | Cuba | 100%
|
| 3 m | Jamaica | 95%
|
| 22.3 m | Hispaniola | 93%
|
| 1.3 m | Trinidad | 93%
|
| 8 m | Long Island | 88%
|
| 167 k | Saint Lucia | 86%
|
| 279 k | Barbados | 84%
|
| 3.3 m | Puerto Rico | 84%
|
| 1.7 m | Manhattan Island | 79%
|
| 870 k | Vancouver Island | 77%
|
| 496 k | Staten Island | 67%
|
| 522 k | Newfoundland | 65%
|
| 109 k | Saint Vincent | 63%
|
| 390 k | Martinique | 58%
|
| 2 m | Montreal | 58%
|
| 154 k | Prince Edward Island | 42%
|
| 103 k | Aruba | 40%
|
| 157 k | Curaçao | 40%
|
| 211 k | New Providence | 28%
|
| 198 k | Grande-Terre | 19%
|
| 438 k | Île Jésus | 14%
|
| 219 k | Lulu Island | 12%
|
| 132 k | Cape Breton Island | 5%
|
| 169 k | Carmen Island (Campeche) | 2%
|