| Team | # Seasons | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kansas City Royals | 21 | George Brett | 91%
|
| St Louis Cardinals | 22 | Stan Musial | 89%
|
| San Diego Padres | 20 | Tony Gwynn | 89%
|
| Houston Astros | 20 | Craig Biggio | 87%
|
| New York Yankees | 20 | Derek Jeter | 87%
|
| Chicago Cubs | 19 | Ernie Banks | 87%
|
| Milwaukee Brewers | 20 | Robin Yount | 83%
|
| Colorado Rockies | 17 | Todd Helton | 80%
|
| Pittsburgh Pirates | 21 | Willie Stargell | 78%
|
| Baltimore Orioles | 23 | Brooks Robinson | 76%
|
| Atlanter Braves | 19 | Chipper Jones | 76%
|
| Philadelphia Phillies | 18 | Mike Schmidt | 76%
|
| Detroit Tigers | 22 | Al Kaline | 74%
|
| Boston Red Sox | 23 | Carl Yastrezemski | 72%
|
| Seattle Mariners | 18 | Edgar Martinez | 67%
|
| Washington Senators | 21 | Walter Johnson | 61%
|
| Cincinnati Reds | 19 | Dave Concepcion / Barry Larkin | 57%
|
| New York Giants | 22 | Mel Ott | 54%
|
| California/Anaheim/LA Angels | 14 | Tim Salmon | 33%
|
| Minnesota Twins | 15 | Tony Oliva | 28%
|
| New York Mets | 18 | Ed Kranepool | 22%
|
| Los Angeles Dodgers | 18 | Bill Russell | 15%
|
| Montreal Expos | 13 | Steve Rogers | 15%
|
| Chicago White Sox | 21 | Ted Lyons | 13%
|
| Cleveland Indians | 20 | Mel Harder | 9%
|
| Phil/KC Athletics | 13 | Eddie Rommel / Pete Suder | 0%
|