| Population | Island | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| 8,063,232 | Long Island | 100%
|
| 1,694,251 | Manhattan | 95%
|
| 26,444 | Key West | 90%
|
| 1,016,508 | Oahu | 90%
|
| 495,747 | Staten Island | 90%
|
| 200,629 | Hawaii (Big Island) | 85%
|
| 164,221 | Maui | 75%
|
| 3,221,789 | Puerto Rico | 75%
|
| 17,265 | Martha's Vineyard | 70%
|
| 73,298 | Kauai | 65%
|
| 168,801 | Guam | 60%
|
| 54,774 | Galveston Island | 55%
|
| 55,876 | Tutuila | 45%
|
| 73,812 | Alameda Island | 40%
|
| 24,825 | Bainbridge Island | 40%
|
| 38,069 | Hilton Head Island | 40%
|
| 41,004 | Saint Croix | 40%
|
| 43,385 | Saipan | 35%
|
| 69,480 | Whidbey Island | 35%
|
| 21,389 | Grand Island | 30%
|
| 25,748 | Mercer Island | 30%
|
| 60,109 | Rhode Island (Aquidneck Island) | 30%
|
| 42,261 | Saint Thomas | 30%
|
| 53,917 | Absecon Island | 15%
|
| 16,812 | Kent Island | 15%
|
| 20,700 | Fidalgo Island | 10%
|
| 15,760 | Marco Island | 5%
|
| 17,356 | Camano Island | 0%
|
| 21,500 | Johns Island | 0%
|