| Order of Death | Answer | Cause of Death | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1st | Firey | Falling | 100%
|
| 2nd | Rocky | Stabbing | 92%
|
| 4th | Flower | Poisoning | 85%
|
| 5th | Needle | Snapping of the neck | 85%
|
| 6th | Teardrop | Poisoning | 85%
|
| 3rd | Woody | Stabbing/slicing | 85%
|
| 7th | Puffball | Stabbing | 69%
|
| 14th | Bomby | Blood loss | 62%
|
| 20th | Book | Shredding | 62%
|
| 22nd - 23rd | Bubble | Blood loss | 62%
|
| 10th | Coiny | Stabbing | 62%
|
| 9th | Fries | Stabbing | 62%
|
| 8th | Gelatin | Impaling | 62%
|
| 11th | Golf Ball | Bashing/impaling | 62%
|
| 22nd - 23rd | Ice Cube | Blood loss | 62%
|
| 16th | Leafy | Stabbing and blood loss | 62%
|
| 17th | Match | Burning | 62%
|
| 15th | Nickel | Blood loss | 62%
|
| 18th | Pencil | Decapitation | 62%
|
| 19th | Ruby | Shattering | 62%
|
| 13th | Spongy | Ripping | 62%
|
| 12th | Tennis Ball | Stabbing | 62%
|
| 21st | Pin | Unknown (possibly blood loss, possibly stabbing) | 54%
|
| 2nd | Grassy | Stabbing/slicing/cannibalism | 38%
|
| 3rd | Snowball | Stabbing/brain removal | 38%
|
| 1st | Tree | Mutilation | 38%
|
| 5th | Balloony | Popping | 31%
|
| 37th | Balloony | Strangulation/poisoning | 31%
|
| 17th - 22nd | Eggy | Cracked/scrambled | 31%
|
| 14th | Firey Jr | Falling | 31%
|
| 39th | Gaty | Stabbing/live burial | 31%
|
| 13th | Pen | Splitting via automatic door | 31%
|
| 40th - 42nd | Pie | Curb-stomping of head | 31%
|
| 38th | Saw | Impaling/removal of tongue/mutilation | 31%
|
| 10th | Spongy | Ripping | 31%
|
| 25th | Bomby | Exploding | 23%
|
| 40th - 42nd | Bracelety | Mutilation | 23%
|
| 17th - 22nd | Clock | Impaling | 23%
|
| 40th - 42nd | Eraser | Disembowelment | 23%
|
| 8th | Foldy | Trampling | 23%
|
| 26th - 36th | Leafy | Melting | 23%
|
| 43rd | Puffball | Mutilation | 23%
|
| 17th - 22nd | Barf Bag | Burning | 15%
|
| 26th - 36th | David | Burning | 15%
|
| 9th | Dora | Burning | 15%
|
| 11th | Loser | Crushing | 15%
|
| 26th - 36th | Nickel | Burning | 15%
|
| 7th | Remote | Impaling | 15%
|
| 26th - 36th | Robot Flower | Burning | 15%
|
| 16th | Stapy | Crushing | 15%
|
| 15th | Taco | Crushing | 15%
|
| 4th | TV | Burning/stabbing | 15%
|
| 26th - 36th | 8-Ball | Burning | 8%
|
| 17th - 22nd | Cake | Exploding | 8%
|
| 6th | Cloudy | Crushing | 8%
|
| 26th - 36th | Coiny | Burning | 8%
|
| 26th - 36th | Donut | Burning | 8%
|
| 17th - 22nd | Flower | Exploding | 8%
|
| 23rd - 24th | Fries | Crushing | 8%
|
| 26th - 36th | Gaty | Burning | 8%
|
| 26th - 36th | Golf Ball | Burning | 8%
|
| 26th - 36th | Pencil | Burning | 8%
|
| 26th - 36th | Pie | Exploding | 8%
|
| 23rd - 24th | Puffball | Crushing | 8%
|
| 12th | Roboty | Crushing | 8%
|
| 17th - 22nd | Teardrop | Exploding | 8%
|