| Instrument | Years active | Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| GuitarsBacking Vocals | 1981 - 19931997 - 1998 2001 - present | The only member to appear on all studio albums | Gary Holt | 100%
|
| Lead Guitar | 1979 - 1983 | Founding member, also joined a much more influential metal band | Kirk Hammett | 88%
|
| Vocals | 1981 - 19861997 - 1998 2001 - 2002 | Only appears on first album | Paul Baloff | 88%
|
| Vocals | 2005 - 20142025 - present | Most widely disliked vocalist (but I like him) | Rob Dukes | 88%
|
| Vocals | 1986 - 19932002 - 2004 2014 - 2025 | Appears on a majority of the albums | Steve "Zetro" Souza | 88%
|
| Bass | 1997 - 19982001 - present | Bassist with the longest time spent in the band | Jack Gibson | 75%
|
| Drums | 1989 - 1993 | Also played with Testament on Low and First Strike Still Deadly | John Tempesta | 75%
|
| Guitars | 2005 - present | Most recent member to have joined the band | Lee Altus | 75%
|
| Drums | 1979 - 19891997 - 1998 2001 - 2005 2007 - present | Only founding member to currently be in the band (but not on all albums) | Tom Hunting | 75%
|
| Drums | 2005 | Also played in Slayer after both of Dave Lombardo's departures | Paul Bostaph | 63%
|
| Guitars | 1983 - 19931997 - 1998 2001 - 2005 | Appears on all albums from Bonded by Blood to Tempo of the Damned | Rick Hunolt | 63%
|
| Bass | 1983 - 1991 | First bassist to contribute to a studio album | Rob McKillop | 63%
|
| Bass | 1992 | Only appears on one album | Mike Butler | 25%
|