| Team | Year | Position | College | Overall Pick | Player Picked After | Player Picked | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| LVR | 2007 | QB | LSU | 1 | Calvin Johnson | JaMarcus Russell | 75%
|
| DET | 2012 | OT | Iowa | 23 | David DeCastro | Riley Reiff | 25%
|
| MIA | 2010 | LB | Iowa | 119 | Geno Atkins | A.J. Edds | 0%
|
| HOU | 2003 | LB | Cincinnati | 67 | Lance Briggs | Antwan Peek | 0%
|
| DET | 2003 | WR | Michigan State | 2 | Andre Johnson | Chester Rogers | 0%
|
| CAR | 2003 | S | Stanford | 119 | Asante Samuel | Colin Branch | 0%
|
| MIN | 2009 | S | Ole Miss | 231 | Julian Edelman | Jamarca Sanford | 0%
|
| NYJ | 2011 | WR | TCU | 153 | Richard Sherman | Jeremy Kerley | 0%
|
| MIN | 2004 | DE | USC | 20 | Vince Wilfork | Kenechi Udeze | 0%
|
| LAR | 2000 | SS | Iowa | 198 | Tom Brady | Matt Bowen | 0%
|
| PHI | 2012 | LB | California | 46 | Bobby Wagner | Mychal Kendricks | 0%
|
| LVR | 2002 | LB | Northwestern | 23 | Ed Reed | Napoleon Harris | 0%
|
| PIT | 2006 | DT | Miami | 133 | Kyle Williams | Orien Harris | 0%
|
| PIT | 2008 | RB | Illinois | 23 | Chris Johnson | Rashard Mendenhall | 0%
|
| BUF | 2010 | DT | UCF | 41 | Rob Gronkowski | Torell Troup | 0%
|