| Games Played | Years | Main Team | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 335 | 2000-2022 | New England Patriots | Tom Brady | 90%
|
| 287 | 2001-2020 | New Orleans Saints | Drew Brees | 80%
|
| 365 | 1996-2019 | New England Patriots | Adam Vinatieri | 65%
|
| 302 | 1991-2010 | Green Bay Packers | Brett Favre | 60%
|
| 279 | 1985-2003 | Buffalo Bills | Bruce Smith | 55%
|
| 303 | 1985-2004 | San Francisco 49ers | Jerry Rice | 55%
|
| 340 | 1949-1975 | Chicago Bears | George Blanda | 50%
|
| 382 | 1982-2007 | New Orleans Saints | Morten Andersen | 45%
|
| 273 | 1982-1999 | Seattle Seahawks | Norm Johnson | 45%
|
| 295 | 1983-2002 | Washington Redskins | Darrell Green | 40%
|
| 353 | 1982-2004 | Pittsburgh Steelers | Gary Anderson | 35%
|
| 284 | 2000-2018 | Oakland Raiders | Sebastian Janikowski | 35%
|
| 296 | 1983-2001 | Houston Oilers | Bruce Matthews | 30%
|
| 278 | 1978-1996 | Cleveland Browns | Clay Matthews | 30%
|
| 327 | 1992-2012 | Detroit Lions | Jason Hanson | 20%
|
| 286 | 2000-2017 | Oakland Raiders | Shane Lechler | 20%
|
| 282 | 1960-1979 | Minnesota Vikings | Jim Marshall | 15%
|
| 297 | 2004- | San Francisco 49ers | Andy Lee | 10%
|
| 352 | 1988-2009 | New York Giants | Jeff Feagles | 5%
|
| 302 | 1988-2010 | San Diego Chargers | John Carney | 5%
|
| 297 | 1991-2009 | Baltimore Ravens | Matt Stover | 5%
|
| 284 | 1985-2005 | New York Giants | Sean Landeta | 5%
|
| 301 | 1991-2011 | Carolina Panthers | John Kasay | 0%
|
| 305 | 1999-2018 | San Francisco 49ers | Phil Dawson | 0%
|
| 281 | 1983-2002 | Seattle Seahawks | Trey Junkin | 0%
|