| Game | Play Name | Player(s) | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2017 NFC Divisional | Minneapolis Miracle | Case Keenum/Stefon Diggs | 91%
|
| Week 12, 2012 | The Butt Fumble | Mark Sanchez/Brandon Moore/Steve Gregory | 78%
|
| 2010 NFC Wild Card | Beastquake | Marshawn Lynch | 78%
|
| Super Bowl XLII | Helmet Catch | Eli Manning/David Tyree | 74%
|
| 1972 AFC Divisional | The Immaculate Reception | Terry Bradshaw/Franco Harris | 65%
|
| 1981 NFC Championship | The Catch | Joe Montana/Dwight Clark | 61%
|
| 1999 AFC Wild Card | The Music City Miracle | Lorenzo Neal/Frank Wycheck/Kevin Dyson | 52%
|
| Super Bowl XLIX | The Interception | Russell Wilson/Malcolm Butler | 52%
|
| Week 14, 2018 | The Miami Miracle | Ryan Tannehill/Kenny Stills/Devante Parker/Kenyan Drake | 52%
|
| Super Bowl XXXIV | The Tackle/One Yard Short | Steve McNair/Kevin Dyson/Mike Jones | 48%
|
| 1998 NFC Wild Card | The Catch II | Steve Young/Terrell Owens | 48%
|
| 1967 NFL Championship | Ice Bowl Sneak | Bart Starr | 39%
|
| 2011 NFC Divisional | The Catch III | Alex Smith/Vernon Davis | 35%
|
| Week 15, 2010 | Miracle at the New Meadowlands | Matt Dodge/Desean Jackson | 35%
|
| 1974 AFC Divisional | The Sea of Hands | Ken Stabler/Clarence Davis | 26%
|
| Week 13, 1978 | The Miracle at the Meadowlands | Joe Pisarcik/Larry Csonka/Herman Edwards | 22%
|
| Super Bowl LIV | Jet Chip Wasp | Patrick Mahomes/Tyreek Hill | 22%
|
| 1975 NFC Divisional | The Hail Mary | Roger Staubach/Drew Pearson | 22%
|
| 1987 AFC Championship | The Fumble | Ernest Byner/Jeremiah Castille | 13%
|
| 1977 AFC Championship | The Ghost to the Post | Ken Stabler/Dave Casper | 13%
|
| Week 1, 1978 | The Holy Roller | Ken Stabler/Dave Casper | 13%
|
| Super Bowl XXV | Wide Right | Scott Norwood | 13%
|
| 2015 NFC Wild Card | The Shank at the Bank | Blair Walsh | 9%
|
| Super Bowl XLIV | Ambush Onside Kick | Thomas Morstead/Chris Reis | 9%
|
| Week 16, 2002 | The River City Relay | Aaron Brooks/Dante Stallworth/Deuce McAllister/Jerome Pathon | 4%
|