| Name | College | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Bobby Garrett | Stanford | 92%
|
| Jim Plunkett | Stanford | 92%
|
| John Elway | Stanford | 92%
|
| Andrew Luck | Stanford | 92%
|
| Tommy Nobis | Texas | 92%
|
| Earl Campbell | Texas | 92%
|
| Kenneth Sims | Texas | 92%
|
| Jameis Winston | Florida State | 89%
|
| Frank Sinkwich | Georgia | 89%
|
| Charley Trippi | Georgia | 89%
|
| Harry Babcock | Georgia | 89%
|
| Matthew Stafford | Georgia | 89%
|
| Tucker Frederickson | Auburn | 88%
|
| Bo Jackson | Auburn | 88%
|
| Aundray Bruce | Auburn | 88%
|
| Cam Newton | Auburn | 88%
|
| Billy Cannon | LSU | 88%
|
| JaMarcus Russell | LSU | 88%
|
| Lee Roy Selmon | Oklahoma | 87%
|
| Billy Sims | Oklahoma | 87%
|
| Sam Bradford | Oklahoma | 87%
|
| George Cafego | Tennessee | 84%
|
| Peyton Manning | Tennessee | 84%
|
| Ed Jones | Tennessee State | 84%
|
| Tom Harmon | Michigan | 83%
|
| Jake Long | Michigan | 83%
|
| Ron Yary | USC | 83%
|
| O.J. Simpson | USC | 83%
|
| Ricky Bell | USC | 83%
|
| Keyshawn Johnson | USC | 83%
|
| Carson Palmer | USC | 83%
|
| Steve Bartkowski | California | 81%
|
| Jared Goff | California | 81%
|
| Tom Cousineau | Ohio State | 81%
|
| Dan Wilkinson | Ohio State | 81%
|
| Orlando Pace | Ohio State | 81%
|
| George Rogers | South Carolina | 81%
|
| Jadeveon Clowney | South Carolina | 81%
|
| Myles Garrett | Texas A&M | 81%
|
| Harry Gilmer | Alabama | 79%
|
| Eli Manning | Ole Miss | 78%
|
| Bill Dudley | Virginia | 77%
|
| Troy Aikman | UCLA | 74%
|
| Bruce Smith | Virginia Tech | 72%
|
| Michael Vick | Virginia Tech | 72%
|
| Vinny Testaverde | Miami (FL) | 69%
|
| Russell Maryland | Miami (FL) | 69%
|
| Chuck Bednarik | Penn | 69%
|
| Alex Smith | Utah | 65%
|
| Bubba Smith | Michigan State | 63%
|
| Ki-Jana Carter | Penn State | 61%
|
| Courtney Brown | Penn State | 61%
|
| Steve Emtman | Washington | 60%
|
| George Shaw | Oregon | 59%
|
| David Carr | Fresno State | 56%
|
| Angelo Bertelli | Notre Dame | 56%
|
| Frank Dancewicz | Notre Dame | 56%
|
| Leon Hart | Notre Dame | 56%
|
| Paul Hornung | Notre Dame | 56%
|
| Walt Patulski | Notre Dame | 56%
|
| Tim Couch | Kentucky | 52%
|
| Sam Francis | Nebraska | 49%
|
| Irving Fryar | Nebraska | 49%
|
| Dave Parks | Texas Tech | 49%
|
| Drew Bledsoe | Washington State | 49%
|
| Bob Fenimore | Oklahoma State | 47%
|
| Jeff George | Illinois | 44%
|
| Ernie Davis | Syracuse | 41%
|
| Terry Baker | Oregon State | 39%
|
| Randy Duncan | Iowa | 38%
|
| Mario Williams | NC State | 38%
|
| Eric Fisher | Central Michigan | 37%
|
| Corbett Davis | Indiana | 33%
|
| Terry Bradshaw | Louisiana Tech | 32%
|
| Ki Aldrich | TCU | 30%
|
| Gary Glick | Colorado State | 19%
|
| Bill Wade | Vanderbilt | 17%
|
| Kyle Rote | SMU | 16%
|
| Jay Berwanger | Chicago | 15%
|
| Tommy Mason | Tulane | 11%
|
| King Hill | Rice | 10%
|
| John Matuszak | Tampa | 5%
|