| Answer | % Correct | |
|---|---|---|
| A killer that killed his parents, but spared his brother | Jeff the Killer | 99%
|
| A pale, no-faced man with a suit and tie | Slenderman | 96%
|
| He drowned | Ben | 95%
|
| A supposed killer who wants revenge on Jeff the Killer | Jane the Killer | 94%
|
| The scary side of Sonic | Sonic. EXE | 89%
|
| A kidney eater | Eyeless Jack | 88%
|
| A cursed photo of a creepy animal | Smile Dog | 87%
|
| A clown that brutally murders children | Laughing Jack | 86%
|
| A killer who wears a mask | Masky | 86%
|
| A crazed killer that wields two axes | Ticci Toby | 80%
|
| A unidentified killer from MarbleHornets | Hoodie | 77%
|
| A young girl who killed her entire family | Sally | 76%
|
| A haunted sonic doll | Tails Doll | 66%
|
| A creepy, hunched alien creature | Rake | 62%
|
| A haunted part of Pokémon | Lost Silver | 57%
|
| An entity believed to cause insanity or death | Zalgo | 52%
|
| A creepy pirate puppet show | Candle Cove | 38%
|
| A skeleton marionette | Skin Taker | 36%
|
| A bird creature who stalks on young children | Seedeater | 35%
|