| Description | Character | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| The main protagonist of the game who the player plays as | Arthur Morgan | 92%
|
| The leader of the Van der Linde Gang | Dutch van der Linde | 92%
|
| The only child in the gang that Arthur takes on a fishing trip | Jack Marston | 90%
|
| The secondary protagonist and partner in crime of Arthur | John Marston | 90%
|
| He suffers from terminal lumbago and lazes around camp all day | Uncle | 88%
|
| A Mexican gunman who remains incredibly loyal to the gang | Javier Escuella | 87%
|
| A young, African-American gunman who joined the gang at a young age | Lenny Summers | 87%
|
| The camp cook and former Navy member | Pearson | 87%
|
| The mother of Jack Marston and wife of John Marston | Abigail Roberts | 86%
|
| The co-founder and 2nd in command of the Van der Linde Gang | Hosea Matthews | 86%
|
| The main antagonist of the game of who is very violent and merciless | Micah Bell | 84%
|
| A quiet and reserved Native American who is highly skilled at tracking and hunting | Charles Smith | 83%
|
| A gunwoman and bounty hunter who used to own a ranch deep in the mountains | Sadie Adler | 83%
|
| A young, Irish thief who partakes in several heists in the early story | Sean MacGuire | 83%
|
| A former O'Driscoll that was captured by Arthur in the first chapter | Kieran Duffy | 80%
|
| This Irish lady fell deeply in love with Dutch | Molly O'Shea | 80%
|
| An Austrian bookkeeper and accountant | Leopold Strauss | 79%
|
| A former military man who was dishonorably discharged, leading to a life of violence | Bill Williamson | 78%
|
| A young, intelligent girl who was, at one point, kidnapped by the Foreman Brothers | Tilly Jackson | 77%
|
| Alongside Pearson, she keeps the camp in order and does the packing/unpacking when the gang moves | Susan Grimshaw | 76%
|
| This member is a religious drunk that regularly wanders around camp singing | Reverend Swanson | 75%
|
| A young, orphan girl who dreams of being a novel writer but excels in pick-pocketing | Mary-Beth Gaskill | 70%
|
| A gunwoman, thief, and keen scam artist | Karen Jones | 69%
|
| A conman and secret associate for the Van der Linde Gang | Josiah Trelawny | 65%
|