| Letter | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| I | I Bet On Losing Dogs / I Don't Like My Mind / I Don't Smoke / I Guess / I Love Me After You / I'm Your Man / I Want You / I Will | 84%
|
| B | Bag of Bones / Because Dreaming Costs Money, My Dear / Blue Light / Brand New City / Buffalo Replaced / Bug Like an Angel / A Burning Hill | 83%
|
| C | Carry Me Out / Circle / Class of 2013 / Come into the Water / Crack Baby | 81%
|
| F | Fireworks / First Love Late Spring / Francis Forever / The Frost | 81%
|
| L | Last Words of a Shooting Star / Liquid Smooth / Lonesome Love / Love Me More / A Loving Feeling | 79%
|
| W | Washing Machine Heart / When Memories Snow / Why Didn't You Stop Me? / Wife / Working for the Knife | 79%
|
| P | A Pearl / Pearl Diver / Pink in the Night | 76%
|
| D | Dan the Dancer / The Deal / Door / Drunk Walk Home | 74%
|
| S | Shame / Should've Been Me / Square / Star / Stay Soft / Strawberry Blond | 74%
|
| M | Me and My Husband / My Body's Made of Crushed Little Stars / My Love Mine All Mine | 72%
|
| H | Happy / Heat Lightning / Heaven / A Horse Named Cold Air / Humpty | 71%
|
| N | Nobody | 70%
|
| T | Texas Reznikoff / That's Our Lamp / There's Nothing Left for You / Thursday Girl / Townie / Two Slow Dancers | 65%
|
| E | Eric / Everyone | 63%
|
| G | Geyser / Goodbye, My Danish Sweetheart | 63%
|
| A | Abbey | 61%
|
| O | Old Friend / Once More to See You / The Only Heartbreaker | 54%
|
| R | Real Men / Remember My Name | 50%
|
| J | Jobless Monday | 48%
|
| Y | Your Best American Girl | 46%
|
| V | Valentine, Texas | 37%
|