| Artist | Island | Year | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Barry Manilow | {Bermuda} Triangle | 1981 | 100%
|
| Elvis Presley | Blue {Hawaii} | 1961 | 76%
|
| Wings | {Mull} of Kintyre | 1978 | 67%
|
| Typically Tropical | Barbados | 1975 | 62%
|
| Bertie Higgins | Key {Largo} | 1981 | 62%
|
| Leonard Cohen | First We Take {Manhattan} | 1987 | 52%
|
| The Corries | The {Skye} Boat Song | 1961 | 52%
|
| The Vengaboys | We're Going to {Ibiza} | 1999 | 48%
|
| Souixsie and the Banshees | {Hong} {Kong} Garden | 1978 | 43%
|
| Tom Browne | Funkin' for {Jamaica} | 1980 | 38%
|
| Perry Como | {Bali} Hai | 1949 | 33%
|
| Johnny Cash | {Rock} Island Line | 1972 | 29%
|
| Flanders and Swann | {Madeira} M'Dear | 1957 | 10%
|
| The Four Preps | 26 Miles (Santa {Catalina}) | 1958 | 5%
|
| The Gaylords | Isle of {Capri} | 1954 | 5%
|
| Fleet Foxes | Mykonos | 2009 | 5%
|