| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Micah Bell | John Marston | 87%
|
| Arthur Morgan (Low Honor) | Micah Bell | 87%
|
| Bill Williamson | John Marston | 81%
|
| Angelo Bronte | Dutch Van Der Linde | 59%
|
| Kieran Duffy | O'Driscoll | 57%
|
| Arthur Morgan (High Honor) | Tuberculosis | 57%
|
| Hosea Matthews | Agent Milton | 56%
|
| Agent Ross | Jack Marston | 56%
|
| Molly O'Shea | Susan Grimshaw | 55%
|
| Dutch Van Der Linde | Himself | 54%
|
| Leviticus Cornwall | Dutch Van Der Linde | 52%
|
| Agent Milton | Abigail Roberts | 48%
|
| Susan Grimshaw | Micah Bell | 45%
|
| Lenny Summers | Pinkerton | 45%
|
| Alberto Fussar | Arthur Morgan | 36%
|
| Colonel Favours | Arthur Morgan | 28%
|
| Eagle Flies | Colonel Favours | 25%
|
| John Marston | Government | 13%
|
| Jack Marston | Old Age | 13%
|
| Colm O'Driscoll | Government | 11%
|
| Abigail Roberts | Disease | 9%
|