| # of Years | Team | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| 107 | Chicago Cubs | 99%
|
| 67 | Cleveland Indians | 84%
|
| 0 | Kansas City Royals | 61%
|
| 1 | San Francisco Giants | 60%
|
| 2 | Boston Red Sox | 57%
|
| 6 | New York Yankees | 57%
|
| 4 | St. Louis Cardinals | 57%
|
| 55* | Texas Rangers/Washington Senators | 55%
|
| 27 | Los Angeles Dodgers | 53%
|
| 26 | Oakland Athletics | 53%
|
| 7 | Philadelphia Phillies | 52%
|
| 14 | Arizona Diamondbacks | 51%
|
| 25 | Cincinnati Reds | 51%
|
| 12 | Miami Marlins | 51%
|
| 24 | Minnesota Twins | 51%
|
| 20 | Atlanta Braves | 50%
|
| 10 | Chicago White Sox | 50%
|
| 29 | New York Mets | 50%
|
| 36 | Pittsburgh Pirates | 50%
|
| 31 | Detroit Tigers | 49%
|
| 13 | Los Angeles Angels | 49%
|
| 54* | Houston Astros/Colt .45s | 48%
|
| 22 | Toronto Blue Jays | 48%
|
| 47* | San Diego Padres | 47%
|
| 47* | Washington Nationals/Montreal Expos | 47%
|
| 32 | Baltimore Orioles | 46%
|
| 23* | Colorado Rockies | 46%
|
| 47* | Milwaukee Brewers/Seattle Pilots | 45%
|
| 39* | Seattle Mariners | 43%
|
| 18* | Tampa Bay Rays | 43%
|