| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Shelby Corcoran, Show Choir Coach | Idina Menzel | 79%
|
| Holly Holiday, Substitute Teacher | Gwyneth Paltrow | 76%
|
| Cassandra July, NYADA Dance Teacher | Kate Hudson | 75%
|
| Carl Howell, Emma's Ex-Boyfriend | John Stamos | 69%
|
| Bryan Ryan, Will's Les Miserables Rival | Neil Patrick Harris | 69%
|
| Carmen Thibideaux, NYADA Dean | Whoopi Goldberg | 64%
|
| David Martinez, Spanish Teacher | Ricky Martin | 61%
|
| Jesse St. James, Rival and Ex-Boyfriend | Jonathan Groff | 60%
|
| Isabelle Wright, Vogue.com Editor | Sarah Jessica Parker | 57%
|
| Hiram Berry, Rachel's Father | Jeff Goldblum | 35%
|
| Cooper Anderson, Blaine's Brother | Matt Bomer | 33%
|
| Roz Washington, Champion Swimming Coach | NeNe Leakes | 31%
|
| Maribel Lopez, Santana's Mother | Gloria Estefan | 28%
|
| Doris Sylvester, Sue's Mother | Carol Burnett | 21%
|
| Inner Voice of Becky Jackson | Helen Mirren | 21%
|