| Hint | Character | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Protagonist | Henry Hill | 100%
|
| Protagonist's Wife | Karen Hill | 58%
|
| Psychopathic Antagonist | Tommy DeVito | 48%
|
| Wealthy Secondary Protagonist | James Conway | 40%
|
| Protagonist's First Boss | Paulie Cicero | 26%
|
| Protagonist's Mistress | Janice Rossi | 12%
|
| First Boss' Brother | Tuddy Cicero | 12%
|
| Lucchese Crime Family Associate | Frankie Carbone | 8%
|
| Mistress' Friend | Sandy | 8%
|
| One-Liner Comedian | Henny Youngman | 4%
|
| Antagonistic "Made Man" | Billy Battz | 2%
|
| Protagonist's Wife's Neighbor | Bruce | 2%
|
| Bamboo Lounge Owner | Sonny Bunz | 2%
|
| Wig Shop Owner's Wife | Belle Kessler | 0%
|
| Heist Criminal | Frenchy | 0%
|
| Wig Shop Owner | Morris Kesler | 0%
|