| Player | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Odell Beckham Jr. | LSU | 95%
|
| Najee Harris | Alabama | 94%
|
| Tom Brady | Michigan | 94%
|
| Justin Tucker | Texas | 92%
|
| Josh Allen | Wyoming | 92%
|
| Baker Mayfield | Oklahoma | 91%
|
| Noah Fant | Iowa | 90%
|
| Chris Olave | Ohio State | 89%
|
| Patrick Mahomes | Texas Tech | 89%
|
| Peyton Manning | Tennessee | 88%
|
| Cam Newton | Auburn | 87%
|
| Brock Purdy | Iowa State | 86%
|
| Rob Gronkowski | Arizona | 84%
|
| Kirk Cousins | Michigan State | 83%
|
| Micah Parsons | Penn State | 83%
|
| Emmitt Smith | Florida | 81%
|
| Deion Sanders | Florida State | 77%
|
| Jason Kelce | Cincinnati | 74%
|
| Tony Gonzalez | Cal | 73%
|
| Daniel Jones | Duke | 73%
|
| Derek Carr | Fresno State | 72%
|
| Champ Bailey | Georgia | 65%
|
| Brandon Aiyuk | Arizona State | 59%
|
| Taysom Hill | BYU | 58%
|
| Steve Young | BYU | 58%
|
| Lawrence Taylor | North Carolina | 57%
|
| Brian Dawkins | Clemson | 55%
|
| Tyler Lockett | Kansas State | 55%
|
| Zach Ertz | Stanford | 55%
|
| John Elway | Stanford | 55%
|
| Khalil Mack | Buffalo | 51%
|
| Rashod Bateman | Minnesota | 49%
|
| Joe Thomas | Wisconsin | 49%
|
| Bradley Chubb | NC State | 46%
|
| Ameer Abdullah | Nebraska | 43%
|
| Dick Butkus | Illinois | 38%
|
| Fletcher Cox | Mississippi State | 36%
|
| Maxx Crosby | Eastern Michigan | 35%
|
| Adam Gotsis | Georgia Tech | 30%
|
| Johnny Unitas | Louisville | 30%
|
| Brian Urlacher | New Mexico | 30%
|
| Steve Atwater | Arkansas | 29%
|
| Mike Singletary | Baylor | 29%
|
| Justin Simmons | Boston College | 27%
|
| Terry Bradshaw | Louisiana Tech | 27%
|
| Emmanuel Sanders | SMU | 23%
|
| Walter Payton | Jackson State | 20%
|
| Jake Elliot | Memphis | 18%
|
| Jason Taylor | Akron | 8%
|
| Vince Lombardi | Fordham | 5%
|