| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Haven't you people ever heard closing the goddamn door?! | I Write Sins not Tragedies | 92%
|
| Song with Brendon's wife's name in the title | Sarah Smiles | 89%
|
| Becomes Satan in the music video | Emperor's New Clothes | 84%
|
| Soundtrack for Jennifer's Body | New Perspective | 75%
|
| Video features people with aquariums of their heads | Lying is the Most Fun a Girl Can Have Without Taking Her Clothes Off | 71%
|
| Begins with children singing in french | Nearly Witches (Ever since we met...) | 70%
|
| First track on "Too Weird to Live, Too Rare to Die" | This is Gospel | 70%
|
| What a wonderful caricature of intamicy | Build God, Then We'll Talk | 65%
|
| Heavily inspired by Frank Sinatra | Death of a Bachelor | 65%
|
| In the middle of the summer/All was golden in the sky! | When the Day Met the Night | 61%
|
| First track on "Pretty.Odd" | We're So Starving | 49%
|
| Collaboration with Fun | C'mon | 47%
|
| Ends with a minute of elevator music | The Calendar | 27%
|
| Drums inspired by 'Sing, Sing, Sing' | Crazy=Genius | 13%
|
| Samples a song from Chicago | Hallelujah | 12%
|