| Position | Player | College | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| RB* | Barry Sanders | Oklahoma State | 96%
|
| RB | Thurman Thomas | Oklahoma State | 96%
|
| WR* | Cris Carter | Ohio State | 94%
|
| RB* | Emmitt Smith | Florida | 93%
|
| QB* | John Elway | Stanford | 91%
|
| CB* | Deion Sanders | Florida State | 88%
|
| S* | LeRoy Butler | Florida State | 88%
|
| WR | Michael Irvin | Miami | 88%
|
| DT* | Cortez Kennedy | Miami | 88%
|
| DT | Warren Sapp | Miami | 88%
|
| LB* | Derrick Thomas | Alabama | 87%
|
| LB | Cornelius Bennett | Alabama | 87%
|
| OT | Tony Boselli | USC | 85%
|
| OG* | Bruce Matthews | USC | 85%
|
| LB* | Junior Seau | USC | 85%
|
| S | Ronnie Lott | USC | 85%
|
| RB | Terrell Davis | Georgia | 84%
|
| WR | Tim Brown | Notre Dame | 78%
|
| DT | Bryant Young | Notre Dame | 78%
|
| S | Carnell Lake | UCLA | 78%
|
| CB | Aeneas Williams | Southern | 76%
|
| QB | Brett Favre | Southern Miss | 76%
|
| K* | Morten Anderson | Michigan State | 74%
|
| LB | Hardy Nickerson | California | 69%
|
| DE* | Reggie White | Tennessee | 69%
|
| OG | Steve Wisniewski | Penn State | 68%
|
| OT | Richmond Webb | Texas A&M | 66%
|
| DE* | Bruce Smith | Virginia Tech | 66%
|
| OT* | Gary Zimmerman | Oregon | 65%
|
| LB* | Kevin Greene | Auburn | 63%
|
| KR* | Michael Bates | Arizona | 59%
|
| OG* | Randall McDaniel | Arizona State | 59%
|
| WR* | Jerry Rice | Mississippi Valley State | 57%
|
| DE | Neil Smith | Nebraska | 56%
|
| LB | Levon Kirkland | Clemson | 53%
|
| S* | Steve Atwater | Arkansas | 49%
|
| C* | Dermontti Dawson | Kentucky | 49%
|
| CB* | Rod Woodson | Purdue | 46%
|
| PR | Mel Gray | Purdue | 46%
|
| C | Mark Stepnoski | Pittsburgh | 44%
|
| DE | Chris Doleman | Pittsburgh | 44%
|
| K | Gary Anderson | Syracuse | 41%
|
| TE* | Shannon Sharpe | Savannah State | 31%
|
| OT* | Willie Roaf | Louisiana Tech | 19%
|
| OG | Larry Allen | Sonoma State | 13%
|
| DT* | John Randle | Texas A&I | 9%
|
| CB | Darrell Green | Texas A&I | 9%
|
| TE | Ben Coates | Livingstone | 6%
|
| P | Sean Landeta | Towson | 4%
|