| Position | Player | College | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| QB* | Tom Brady | Michigan | 100%
|
| OG* | Steve Hutchinson | Michigan | 100%
|
| CB* | Charles Woodson | Michigan | 100%
|
| CB | Ty Law | Michigan | 100%
|
| QB | Peyton Manning | Tennessee | 95%
|
| RB | Jamal Lewis | Tennessee | 95%
|
| RB* | Edgerrin James | Miami | 89%
|
| DT* | Warren Sapp | Miami | 89%
|
| LB* | Ray Lewis | Miami | 89%
|
| S* | Ed Reed | Miami | 89%
|
| PR | Devin Hester | Miami | 89%
|
| RB | Shaun Alexander | Alabama | 88%
|
| OT | Orlando Pace | Ohio State | 87%
|
| DT* | Richard Seymour | Georgia | 85%
|
| CB* | Champ Bailey | Georgia | 85%
|
| S | Troy Polamalu | USC | 84%
|
| WR* | Randy Moss | Marshall | 82%
|
| RB* | LaDainian Tomlinson | TCU | 79%
|
| TE* | Tony Gonzalez | California | 74%
|
| DE | Julius Peppers | North Carolina | 74%
|
| OT* | Walter Jones | Florida State | 72%
|
| LB* | Derrick Brooks | Florida State | 72%
|
| OT* | Jonathan Ogden | UCLA | 69%
|
| P* | Shane Lechler | Texas A&M | 68%
|
| PR* | Dante Hall | Texas A&M | 68%
|
| OG* | Alan Faneca | LSU | 65%
|
| C* | Kevin Mawae | LSU | 65%
|
| LB | Zach Thomas | Texas Tech | 58%
|
| CB | Ronde Barber | Virginia | 56%
|
| FB | Tony Richardson | Auburn | 53%
|
| WR* | Marvin Harrison | Syracuse | 52%
|
| DE* | Dwight Freeney | Syracuse | 52%
|
| C | Olin Kreutz | Washington | 52%
|
| WR | Torry Holt | NC State | 49%
|
| DT | Kevin Williams | Oklahoma State | 48%
|
| S* | Brian Dawkins | Clemson | 47%
|
| LB* | Brian Urlacher | New Mexico | 44%
|
| OG | Will Shields | Nebraska | 42%
|
| TE | Antonio Gates | Kent State | 38%
|
| KR* | Joshua Cribbs | Kent State | 38%
|
| DT | La'Roi Glover | San Diego State | 31%
|
| LB | DeMarcus Ware | Troy | 31%
|
| LB | Joey Porter | Colorado State | 29%
|
| WR | Terrell Owens | Chattanooga | 28%
|
| K | David Akers | Louisville | 26%
|
| FB* | Lorenzo Neal | Fresno State | 25%
|
| K* | Adam Vinatieri | South Dakota State | 25%
|
| OT | Willie Roaf | Louisiana Tech | 22%
|
| DE | Jason Taylor | Akron | 19%
|
| DE* | Michael Strahan | Texas Southern | 16%
|
| OG | Larry Allen | Sonoma State | 13%
|
| S | Darren Sharper | William & Mary | 13%
|
| P | Brian Moorman | Pittsburg State | 5%
|