| Player | Position | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tom Brady | QB | Michigan | 98%
|
| Elroy Hirsch | WR | Michigan | 98%
|
| Bill Hewitt | DE | Michigan | 98%
|
| Peyton Manning | QB | Tennessee | 90%
|
| Doug Atkins | DE | Tennessee | 90%
|
| Reggie White | DE | Tennessee | 90%
|
| Don Hutson | WR | Alabama | 89%
|
| John Hannah | OG | Alabama | 89%
|
| Dwight Stephenson | C | Alabama | 89%
|
| Emmitt Smith | RB | Florida | 88%
|
| Lee Roy Selmon | DE | Oklahoma | 86%
|
| Earl Campbell | RB | Texas | 86%
|
| O.J. Simpson | RB | USC | 86%
|
| Anthony Muñoz | OT | USC | 86%
|
| Bruce Matthews | OG | USC | 86%
|
| Junior Seau | LB | USC | 86%
|
| Ronnie Lott | S | USC | 86%
|
| Walter Jones | OT | Florida State | 85%
|
| Derrick Brooks | LB | Florida State | 85%
|
| Deion Sanders | CB | Florida State | 85%
|
| Jim Otto | C | Miami | 84%
|
| Ted Hendricks | LB | Miami | 84%
|
| Ray Lewis | LB | Miami | 84%
|
| Ed Reed | S | Miami | 84%
|
| Devin Hester | KR | Miami | 84%
|
| Paul Warfield | WR | Ohio State | 84%
|
| Jim Parker | OG | Ohio State | 84%
|
| Rob Gronkowski | TE | Arizona | 81%
|
| Joe Montana | QB | Notre Dame | 80%
|
| Alan Page | DT | Notre Dame | 80%
|
| Barry Sanders | RB | Oklahoma State | 78%
|
| Dan Marino | QB | Pittsburgh | 76%
|
| Larry Fitzgerald | WR | Pittsburgh | 76%
|
| Mike Ditka | TE | Pittsburgh | 76%
|
| Joe Schmidt | LB | Pittsburgh | 76%
|
| Jonathan Ogden | OT | UCLA | 76%
|
| John Elway | QB | Stanford | 72%
|
| Tony Gonzalez | TE | California | 71%
|
| Lawrence Taylor | LB | North Carolina | 70%
|
| Chuck Bednarik | LB | Pennsylvania | 69%
|
| Steve Van Buren | RB | LSU | 67%
|
| Randy Moss | WR | Marshall | 66%
|
| Steve Largent | WR | Texas A&M | 64%
|
| Gene Upshaw | OG | Texas A&M | 64%
|
| John Randle | DT | Texas A&M | 64%
|
| Shane Lechler | P | Texas A&M | 64%
|
| Lenny Moore | RB | Penn State | 63%
|
| Jack Ham | LB | Penn State | 63%
|
| Gale Sayers | RB | Kansas | 61%
|
| Dick Butkus | LB | Illinois | 60%
|
| Jim Brown | RB | Syracuse | 60%
|
| Marvin Harrison | WR | Syracuse | 60%
|
| John Mackey | TE | Syracuse | 60%
|
| Roger Staubach | QB | Navy | 59%
|
| Mel Blount | CB | Southern | 59%
|
| Mike Webster | C | Wisconsin | 59%
|
| Emlen Tunnell | S | Iowa | 58%
|
| Randall McDaniel | OG | Arizona State | 56%
|
| Mike Haynes | CB | Arizona State | 56%
|
| Brett Favre | QB | Southern Miss | 56%
|
| Ray Guy | P | Southern Miss | 56%
|
| Lance Alworth | WR | Arkansas | 55%
|
| Bruce Smith | DE | Virginia Tech | 55%
|
| Bobby Bell | LB | Minnesota | 54%
|
| Mel Hein | C | Washington State | 52%
|
| Kellen Winslow | TE | Missouri | 50%
|
| Larry Wilson | S | Utah | 50%
|
| Randy White | DT | Maryland | 48%
|
| Rod Woodson | CB | Purdue | 48%
|
| Sammy Baugh | QB | TCU | 48%
|
| Bob Lilly | DT | TCU | 48%
|
| Johnny Unitas | QB | Louisville | 47%
|
| Eric Dickerson | RB | SMU | 46%
|
| Raymond Berry | WR | SMU | 46%
|
| Forrest Gregg | OT | SMU | 46%
|
| Jack Christiansen | S | Colorado State | 38%
|
| Otto Graham | QB | Northwestern | 38%
|
| Darrell Green | CB | Texas A&I | 38%
|
| Merlin Olsen | DT | Utah State | 34%
|
| Jerry Rice | WR | Mississippi Valley State | 32%
|
| Deacon Jones | DE | Mississippi Valley State | 32%
|
| Marion Motley | RB | Nevada | 32%
|
| Walter Payton | RB | Jackson State | 29%
|
| Adam Vinatieri | K | South Dakota State | 22%
|
| Joe Greene | DT | North Texas | 19%
|
| Jack Lambert | LB | Kent State | 17%
|
| Jan Stenerud | K | Montana State | 11%
|
| Buck Buchanan | DT | Grambling State | 9%
|
| Willie Brown | CB | Grambling State | 9%
|
| Gino Marchetti | DE | San Francisco | 6%
|
| Larry Allen | OG | Sonoma State | 5%
|
| Dan Fortmann | OG | Colgate | 3%
|
| Dutch Clark | RB | Colorado College | 3%
|
| Art Shell | OT | Maryland Eastern Shore | 3%
|
| Rosey Brown | OT | Morgan State | 3%
|
| Willie Lanier | LB | Morgan State | 3%
|
| Ken Houston | S | Prairie View A&M | 2%
|
| Dick "Night Train" Lane | CB | Western Nebraska Community College | 2%
|
| Billy "White Shoes" Johnson | PR | Widener | 2%
|
| Cal Hubbard | OT | Geneva College | 1%
|