| Appearance | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Banana | Joe | 90%
|
| Dinosaur | Tina | 86%
|
| Ghost | Carrie | 82%
|
| Balloon | Alan | 80%
|
| Flower | Leslie | 75%
|
| Robot | Bobert | 70%
|
| Shapeshifting Fairy | Penny | 70%
|
| Ice Cream | Sarah | 70%
|
| Rainbow | Tobias | 67%
|
| Cloud | Masami | 58%
|
| Clay | Clayton | 54%
|
| Giant | Hector | 54%
|
| Cactus | Carmen | 51%
|
| Potato | Idaho | 49%
|
| Pixel Spider | Ocho | 45%
|
| Floating Eyeball | William | 45%
|
| Paper Bear | Teri | 38%
|
| Puppet | Sussie | 35%
|
| Toast | Anton | 30%
|
| Half-Cow Half-Troglodyte | Jamie | 24%
|
| Boombox-Head | Juke | 23%
|
| Sauropod | Molly | 23%
|
| Egghead without Glasses | Felix | 11%
|
| Egghead with Glasses | Collin | 9%
|