| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Big Papi | David Ortiz | 89%
|
| Mr. October | Reggie Jackson | 89%
|
| Sandman | Mariano Rivera | 87%
|
| Joltin' Joe | Joe DiMaggio | 84%
|
| The Captain | Derek Jeter | 82%
|
| The Sultan of Swat, The King of Crash, The Colossus of Clout and The Great Bambino | George Ruth | 82%
|
| Yogi Berra | Lawrence Berra | 82%
|
| The Big Unit | Randy Johnson | 79%
|
| Charlie Hustle | Pete Rose | 71%
|
| The Hammer | Hank Aaron | 68%
|
| The Man of Steal | Rickey Henderson | 66%
|
| The Commerce Comet | Mickey Mantle | 61%
|
| ARRIBA | Roberto Clemente | 58%
|
| The Millville Meteor | Mike Trout | 53%
|
| The Sultan of Shot | Barry Bonds | 34%
|