| Position | Years | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| QB | 1989–2000 | Troy Aikman | 95%
|
| RB | 1990–2002 | Emmitt Smith | 93%
|
| QB | 1969–1979 | Roger Staubach | 93%
|
| WR | 1988–1999 | Michael Irvin | 90%
|
| Head Coach | 1960–1988 | Tom Landry | 74%
|
| RB | 1977–1987 | Tony Dorsett | 71%
|
| OG, OT | 1994–2005 | Larry Allen | 69%
|
| LB | 2005-2013 | DeMarcus Ware | 67%
|
| WR | 1973–1983 | Drew Pearson | 67%
|
| DT | 1961–1974 | Bob Lilly | 62%
|
| QB | 1960–1968 | Don Meredith | 62%
|
| DT, LB, DE | 1975–1988 | Randy White | 62%
|
| WR | 1965–1974 | Bob Hayes | 50%
|
| DE | 1992–1996 | Charles Haley | 45%
|
| S | 1992–2004 | Darren Woodson | 45%
|
| S | 1970–1979 | Cliff Harris | 38%
|
| CB | 1964–1977 | Mel Renfro | 38%
|
| LB | 1961–1973 | Chuck Howley | 31%
|
| OT | 1967–1979 | Rayfield Wright | 31%
|
| General Manager | 1960–1989 | Tex Schramm | 24%
|
| VP Player Personnel | 1960–1988 | Gil Brandt | 19%
|
| FB | 1961–1968 | Don Perkins | 17%
|
| LB, C | 1963–1976 | Lee Roy Jordan | 17%
|