| Year | Team | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1911: 1 | Tigers | Ty Cobb | 100%
|
| 1911: 3 | Athletics | Eddie Collins | 80%
|
| 1913: 3 | Athletics | Eddie Collins | 80%
|
| 1914: 1 | Athletics | Eddie Collins | 80%
|
| 1911: 4 | Naps | Joe Jackson | 80%
|
| 1913: 2 | Naps | Joe Jackson | 80%
|
| 1914: 5 | Naps | Joe Jackson | 80%
|
| 1911: 5 | Senators | Walter Johnson | 80%
|
| 1912: 3 | Senators | Walter Johnson | 80%
|
| 1913: 1 | Senators | Walter Johnson | 80%
|
| 1913: 5 | Athletics | Home Run Baker | 60%
|
| 1914: 3 | Athletics | Home Run Baker | 60%
|
| 1912: 5 | Red Sox | Smoky Joe Wood | 60%
|
| 1912: 1 | Red Sox | Tris Speaker | 60%
|
| 1913: 4 | Red Sox | Tris Speaker | 60%
|
| 1914: 3 | Tigers | Donie Bush | 40%
|
| 1911: 2 | White Sox | Ed Walsh | 40%
|
| 1912: 2 | White Sox | Ed Walsh | 40%
|
| 1914: 2 | Tigers | Sam Crawford | 40%
|
| 1912: 4 | Senators | Clyde Milan | 20%
|